The Azores Island archipelago has nine major islands and São Miguel is the largest among them, with the city Ponta Delgada (PDL). Azores has a subtropical climate with an annual average temperature of 18°C (64°F). I recommend the first time visitors spend at least two full days (with the hope of finding a clear day) on the island with a rental car to cover all the scenic areas.
Award Booking Flights to Portugal
I booked a one-way TAP business class from JFK to Lisbon (two passengers) for 70,000 Avianca miles ($100 USD taxes), which is one of the best award sweet spots of the program.
Typical cash prices for JFK-Lisbon one-way business class flight


Ponta Delgada (PDL) also has nonstop flights from North America (JFK, EWR, BOS, YUL & YYZ).

Ponta Delgada Accommodations
I highly recommend staying at one of the Mr & Mrs Smith properties in Ponta Delgada which can be booked with IHG points as needed.

Azores Must-see Nature Destinations
Day 1 Itinerary:

Vista do Rei Viewpoint


Sete Cidades

Lagoa do Canario

Miradouro da Boca do Inferno Viewpoint


Parque Estacionamento Ferraria

Day 2 Itinerary:

Nordeste

Lagoa do Fogo (Fogo Lake)

Miradouro do Pico da Barrosa (Barrosa Peak)

Summary
São Miguel Island in the Azores Island archipelago is a must-see destination with breathtaking views of lakes. I highly recommend that you visit this island during your trip to Portugal, which is easy to book with points.